Monday, 16 November 2026
Breaking News
“FOURTH ESTATE” HAS NO FOUNDATION IN THE CONSTITUTION, SAYS KBS SIDHU ON NATIONAL PRESS DAY UT CHANDIGARH DECLARE CHHATH PUJA CELEBERATION AS RESTRICTED HOLIDAY ON NOV. 16 MRSPTU MAIN CAMPUS CLINCHES OVERALL TROPHY AT YOUTH FESTIVAL; SWEEPS THREE OF FIVE CATEGORY TROPHIES  CHANMARI SNATCH WINNER IN STOPPAGE TIME AGAINST DEMPO SC FOR THEIR FIRST WIN OF THE SEASON AFRIDI DEPORTED FROM ETHOPIA: FIVE OPERATIVES LINKED TO HIS ORGANISED CRIMINAL NETWORK HELD WITH 11 PISTOLS, 191 CARTRIDGES VISUALLY IMPAIRED 19-YEAR-OLD GIRL MARCHES IN PERFECT SYNC WITH SIGHTED COMPANIONS AT HUSSAINIWALA UNCLE HONOURED BY PRESIDENT FOR SOCIAL SERVICE, NIECE SAANVI MEETS PRESIDENT ON CHILDREN'S DAY; BRINGS PRIDE TO GURUGRAM ‘MITTI DA BAWA’ WINS PUNJABI THEATRE COMPETITION, DEEPAK KAMBOJ ADJUDGED BEST DIRECTOR FREE MEDICAL CAMP HELD AT SECTOR 15-C GURUDWARA IN CHANDIGARH RAMSINGHPUR RAILWAY TRACK BLAST: GURDASPUR NATIVE MAHAKDEEP KAUR AND DAVINDER SINGH ARRESTED
Discussion Trending

“FOURTH ESTATE” HAS NO FOUNDATION IN THE CONSTITUTION, SAYS KBS SIDHU ON NATIONAL PRESS DAY

CALLS FOR A NATIONAL DEBATE ON FIVE QUESTIONS, LED BY THE PRESS AND JOINED BY EVERY POLITICAL PARTY, THE BAR AND CITIZENS

Face2News/Chandigarh 

The press, ceremonially hailed as the Fourth Estate and a pillar of democracy, enjoys no constitutional right or legal privilege beyond those of the ordinary citizen, and the word “press” does not appear anywhere in the chapter on Fundamental Rights, KBS Sidhu, former Special Chief Secretary, Government of Punjab, said today on National Press Day. He called for a national debate, led by the press itself and joined by every political party, the Bar and citizens, on whether freedom of the press should be written into the Constitution and the law.

KBS Sidhu, Founder-Editor of The KBS Chronicle, which has nearly 12,000 subscribers and followers, about half of them outside India, set out his case in an article published this morning. The Supreme Court takes up the news publishers’ challenge to the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 tomorrow, 17 November.

Three findings

*The press is named only as machinery to be regulated. The phrase “freedom of the press” occurs nowhere in the Constitution. The word “press” appears only once, in Entry 39 of the Concurrent List of the Seventh Schedule, “Newspapers, books and printing presses.” That entry gives the press nothing. It gives Parliament and every State Legislature the power to regulate it. In the Constituent Assembly, Dr B.R. Ambedkar held that the press was “merely another way of stating an individual or a citizen.”

*The guarantee is narrow and heavily restricted. Articles 14 and 21 protect “any person.” Article 19, which guarantees free speech, belongs to “all citizens” alone, so a foreign correspondent, and strictly even a newspaper company, has no claim under it. Clause (1)(a) grants the right in one line; clause (2) lists eight grounds on which it may be restricted. “The Constitution giveth with one hand and taketh away with the other,” KBS Sidhu said. “The fundamental right to free speech is best understood not by what it allows but by what may be restricted.”

*The journalist’s source has no protection, and the privacy law widens the gap. India has no shield law. A reporter summoned as a witness by the Enforcement Directorate must answer on oath, cannot withhold his source, and his statement can be used against the accused and later against himself. Criminal defamation still carries imprisonment of up to two years. The DPDP Act dropped the journalistic exemption of the 2018 Srikrishna draft, and lets the Government call for data from any newsroom without a judicial warrant.

“Even the United States, which names the press in its Constitution, treats source protection as a grey area,” KBS Sidhu said. “India does not even begin the conversation. A Minister’s assurance is not a safeguard. Only the text of the law is.”

Five questions for national debate

Name the press. Should Article 19(1)(a) be amended to guarantee freedom of the press in express terms?

Shield the source. Should Parliament enact a qualified privilege for journalistic sources, binding on the police, the ED, the CBI and the Data Protection Board, which only a court can override?

Decriminalise defamation. Should criminal defamation be repealed and replaced by a civil remedy with proportionate damages that cannot bankrupt an individual journalist, and with no right of action for Governments?

Restore the exemption. Should the DPDP Act carry a journalistic exemption, require judicial authorisation before newsroom data is requisitioned, and restore the public-interest override in the RTI Act?

Decide who the press is. Should protection follow the function of journalism, covering the citizen reporter and the independent portal, rather than an accreditation card?
“If a citizen running a modest newsletter can raise these questions on National Press Day, there is no reason why editors, the Press Council, the political parties and the Bar cannot take them up,” KBS Sidhu said. 

0 Comments